Types of Academic Feedback
- Content and argument feedback
- Organizational and structural feedback
- Style and voice feedback
- Technical and formatting feedback
- Distinguishing between major and minor issues
Processing Critical Feedback
- Emotional responses to criticism:
- Recognizing defensive reactions
- Creating space between feedback and response
- Separating your identity from your writing
- Evaluating feedback effectively:
- Considering the source and context
- Looking for patterns across responses
- Distinguishing preferences from requirements
- Balancing multiple perspectives
- Asking clarifying questions:
- Requesting specific examples
- Seeking prioritization of changes
- Confirming understanding of expectations
Implementing Feedback
Creating an action plan
Tracking changes systematically
Following up with feedback providers
Learning from patterns in feedback
Maintaining your voice while addressing concerns